Introcudtion To Infringement Study
Literal Infringement
The PTO does a comparative study of every element of the claim to the product under acquisition. The PTO concludes that there is a literal infringement only if each element explained in the claim is present in the product under acquisition. For example, let us assume that the patent owner of a two wheeled motorcycle claims that a tri-wheeled automobile infringes his patent. Assume that the two wheeled motorcycle only consists of the following claimed parts being front and back wheels, the seat, the suspension holding the seat in position and the handle member. Now patent claims claiming each of these parts would have been written at the time of prosecution of the patent at the PTO.

In a literal infringement analyses, each of the claim elements are read and compared with the tri-wheeled automobile under acquisition. Here the PTO will read each element and conclude that although the tri-wheeled automobile has all features of two wheeled motorcycle but also has one extra wheel. Therefore this is clearly not a case of literal infringement. Then the PTO moves forward to check whether there is an infringement by the ‘doctrine of equivalents’. Under this method, although the claims do not interpret the accused products, if the product performs the same function in the same manner to provide the same result, then the product will be interpreted as an infringing product.

Doctrine of Equivalence:
When the claims of the product under acquisition and the patented product are interpreted by the PTO and if the PTO is unable to find literal infringement then the PTO checks for infringement by the doctrine of equivalence. This is a very subjective and also a highly debated process of patent law in the United States. This section simply describes the fundamentals of this doctrine and what it looks to accomplish.

The foremost investigation to decide whether there is infringement by doctrine of equivalence is to test for functioning of both products, process involved in the working of the products and the result obtained from both the products. This means that is the device under acquisition performs the same function in the same process to produce the same result, then it infringes under the doctrine of equivalence. On a later notice, various decisions have illustrated the “function/process/result” by stating that the difference between the product under acquisition and the patented invention should be non-substantial.

Now let us consider this in the light of the two wheeled motorcycle and tri-wheeled automobile example. Under this example, the tri-wheeled automobile performs the same function in the same process and produces the same result as that of the two wheeled motorcycle. Therefore although the tri-wheeled automobile does not literally infringe, it can be construed to infringe under the doctrine of equivalence.

American Business Models American Patent Office American Trademark Services Automobile patent Benefits of Trademarks Registration Business Methods patents Chemical Patents Attorney Copyright Protection in US Copyright Registration in US Design Patent Application US Design Patent Registration E commerce patent law Electronics patent Lawyer Patent Registration in US What is a trademark? Patent Search Patent Registration in California Patent Lawyer New Jersey US Individual Patent Idea Protection Intellectual Property Law Firm US Intellectual Property Services Mechanical patent Attorney New Jersey Patent Lawyer Patent Application Filing Process Patent Attorney in California US Patent Attorney New Jersey Patent Drafting & Filing Patent Drafting Services New Jersey Patent Firm in US Patent Lawyer California Patent Services Trademark Lawyer California Provisional Patents Registered Trademarks Semiconductor patent attorney Software Patents & Trademarks Trademark Application Filing Process Trademark Attorneys in California US Trademark Consultant in New Jersey Trademark Filing in California Trademark Office US Trademark Lawyer New Jersey Trademark Registration in New Jersey Trademark Registry US Trademark Search in US Trademark Services in New Jersey U.S. Patent Search US Patent Office What Does A Patent Attorney Do? What Does A Patent Attorney Do? Who can apply for a patent
Website Maintenance by Vishishta Technologies